“What Line Can’t Be Measured With a Ruler?”: Riddles and Concept-Formation in Mathematics and Aesthetics

Open Review until 2024-05-12


  • Samuel Wheeler The University of Chicago
  • William Brenner Old Dominion University




Later Wittgenstein, Mathematics, Ludwig Wittgenstein


We analyze two problems in mathematics – the first (stated in our title) is extracted from Wittgenstein’s “Philosophy for Mathematicians”; the second (“What set of numbers is non-denumerable?”) is taken from Cantor. We then consider, by way of comparison, a problem in musical aesthetics concerning a Brahms variation on a theme by Haydn. Our aim is twofold: first, to bring out and elucidate the essentially riddle-like character of these problems; second, to show that the comparison with riddles does not reduce their solution to an exercise in bare subjectivity.

Author Biographies

Samuel Wheeler, The University of Chicago

Samuel J. Wheeler received his B.A. in Philosophy at Old Dominion University and is a PhD student in Philosophy at the University of Chicago. He is the author of "Defending Wittgenstein's Remarks on Cantor from Putnam" and "Wittgenstein on Miscalculation and the Foundations of Mathematics" published in Philosophical Investigations

William Brenner, Old Dominion University

William H. Brenner is Professor Emeritus at Old Dominion University and is author of Logic and Philosophy: An Integrated Introduction and Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations


Baker, G. and Hacker, P.M.S., 1985. An Analytical Commentary on The Philosophical Investigations, Vol. 2. Oxford: Blackwell.

Bold, P., 2022. Three Essays on Later Wittgenstein’s Philosophy of Mathematics: Reality, Determination, & Infinity. PhD diss. University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

Diamond, C., 1991. The Realistic Spirit. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Floyd, J., 1995. “On Saying What You Really Want To Say: Wittgenstein, Gödel, and the Trisection of the Angle”. In: Essays on the Development of the Foundations of Mathematics, ed. J. Hintikka, 373–425.

Floyd, J., 2000. “Wittgenstein, Mathematics and Philosophy”. In: The New Wittgenstein. ed. A. Crary & R. Read. New York, NY: Routledge, 232–261.

Floyd, J., 2010. “On Being Surprised: Wittgenstein on Aspect-Perception, Logic, and Mathematics”. In W. Day & V.J. Krebs (eds.), Seeing Wittgenstein Anew. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Floyd, J. and Mühlhölzer, F., 2020. Wittgenstein’s Annotations to Hardy’s Course of Pure Mathematics: An Investigation of Wittgenstein’s Non-Extensionalist Understanding of the Real Numbers. Cham, Switzerland: Springer Publishing.

Fogelin, R., 2003. Walking the Tightrope of Reason: The Precarious Life of a Rational Animal. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

Mounce. H.O., 1981. Wittgenstein’s Tractatus: An Introduction. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.

Mühlhölzer, F., 2002. “Wittgenstein and Surprises in Mathematics”. In: R. Haller and K. Puhl, eds. Wittgenstein and the Future of Philosophy: A Reassessment after 50 Years. Vienna: öbv&hpt Verlagsgesellschaft, 306–315.

Nir, G., (forthcoming). “Nonsense: A Riddle Without Solution”.In: Early Analytic Philosophy: Origins and Transformations, ed. J. Conant & G. Nir.

Rhees, R., 1965. “Some Developments in Wittgenstein’s View of Ethics”. Philosophical Review 74, 17–26.

Säätelä, S., 2011. “From Logical Method to ‘Messing About’: Wittgenstein on ‘Open Problems’ in Mathematics”. In: The Oxford Handbook of Wittgenstein, ed. O. Kuusela & M. McGinn. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 162–180.

Schroeder, S., 2009. “Conjecture, Proof, and Sense in Wittgenstein’s Philosophy of Mathematics”. In: C. Jäger and W. Löffler (eds.), Epistemology: Contexts, Values, Disagreement. Berlin: De Gruyter.

Schroeder, S., 2020. Wittgenstein on Mathematics. New York, NY: Routledge.

Wheeler, S., 2021. “Defending Wittgenstein’s Remarks on Cantor from Putnam”. Philosophical Investigations 45, 320–333.

Wittgenstein, L., 1953. Philosophical Investigations (Third Edition). Trans. G.E.M. Anscombe. New York, NY: Macmillan Publishing Co., Inc. (PI)

Wittgenstein, L., 1966. Lectures and Conversations on Aesthetic, Psychology, and Religious Belief. Ed. C. Barrett. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. (LA)

Wittgenstein, L., 1967. Zettel. Ed. G.E.M. Anscombe and G.H. von Wright, trans. G.E.M. Anscombe. Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell. (Z)

Wittgenstein, L., 1974. Philosophical Grammar. Ed. Rush Rhees, trans. Anthony Kenny. Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell. (PG)

Wittgenstein, L., 1976. Lectures on the Foundations of Mathematics. Ed. C. Diamond. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. (LFM)

Wittgenstein, L., 1978. Remarks on the Foundations of Mathematics. Ed. G.H. von Wright, R. Rhees, G.E.M. Anscombe, trans. G.E.M. Anscombe. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press. (RFM)

Wittgenstein, L., 1979a. Wittgenstein and the Vienna Circle. Ed. B. McGuinness, trans. J. Schulte and B. McGuinness. Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell. (WWK)

Wittgenstein, L., 1979b. Wittgenstein’s Lectures: Cambridge 1932–1935. Ed. A. Ambrose. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. (AWL)

Wittgenstein, L., 1980. Culture and Value. Ed. G.H. von Wright, trans. P. Winch. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. (CV)

Wittgenstein, L., 1982. Last Writings on the Philosophy of Psychology, Volume I. Ed. G.H. von Wright & Heikki Nyman, trans. C.G. Luckhardt & M.A.E. Aue. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. (LW-I)

Wittgenstein, L., 1988. Wittgenstein's Lectures on Philosophical Psychology, 1946–47. Ed. P.T. Geach. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press. (PGL)

Wittgenstein, L., 1993. Philosophical Occasions, 1912–1951. Ed. J. Klagge and A. Nordman. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing Co. (PO)

Wittgenstein, L., 2013. The Big Typescript: TS 213. Ed. and trans. C.G. Luckhardt and M.A.E. Aue. Oxford, UK: Blackwell. (BT)

Wittgenstein, L., (Unpublished MS). “Ludwig Wittgenstein on ‘Personal Experience’ Macdonald Notes, 1935–1936.” Ed. C. Diamond. (MWL)